Fact of the matter is that most of the Shuffle! cast is damned pathetic.
The yandere who goes nuts from shock, tortures the main idiot, and then spends a few more years repenting, only to hand him away to the very girl she sought help/solstice through.
A tomboy who feels guilty about yelling at her mom for being a nigger baby instead of just dealing with her newly-found blackness and making life awesome for herself by magicing lots and lots of shit to reality as she was technically more powerful than the loli.
The loli with permanent PTSD and no real character whatsoever.
The heaven chick who has deep sister issues and couldn't see that she could land the guy if she had followed her polygamous customs and SEDUCED one of the other girls, increasing her chances at Rin 10,000 fold.
The meek devil bitch who has clone issues, no cooking skills, and also no real characterization.
And of course the coward-assed main character who led on the god bitch, snagged the loli, banged the tomboy, and probably assured the yandere will top the V-Tech massacre by a wide margin. Who couldn't even become an hero properly. Who sucked up years of abuse instead of putting a girl in her place like he should have in the first place if he REALLY fucking cared about her.