She would offer them to me, and I would appreciate her gesture. I'd ask how she had known this was that special day, and she'd reply she didn't know, only that Kyou had told her to do it.
Then I'd giggle and tell her why. She would look puzzled at me for a few moments, then understand it and blush heavily. Then I'd kiss her to approve and take her to the library, where we'd share the chocolate while sitting down barefoot in the ground.
... why can't she be real? ;_;