I can attest to there being cute girls who are into anime. I've met quite a few -- though, coincidentally BEFORE I really got into anime, and now that I have, I meet none. B'aw.
Funny how this thread unfolded, because back when I was just beginning to be a real weeaboo, my now-ex-girlfriend's roommate was the one who introduced me to NANA. She was cute and sane, too, but I'm pretty sure because of the whole ex's-friend politics we could never come close to dating. More b'aw. I just want someone to watch anime with and shlick to my faggoty bishonen hair.