Don't worry. I've been here since late 2005, have been lurking anime communities since 98 or 99, and have been seeing anime for ages; and I think just the same.
Strike Witches is awesome because it tries to be fun. It doesn't make you swallow any DEEP shit. It doesn't play sweet to the censors and feminists. It has a great animation, but some of the scenes are obviously made by some cheap 3D software.
Its charm resides in how it does what it's supposed to: give us a bones, a couple of laughs and a lot of amazing battle scenes and awesome moments.
Of course, the average evafag will hate Strike Witches, but I don't care. They're the ones with their heads on their anuses, not me.