I choose the healthy succubus.
Ice chick would be nice, but yandere = cut off (or in this case frozen) Penis, so no...
Vampire chick would kil me once the rosary is off, and would prevent any sex even with it on.
The younger vampire chick is too tsundere.
Magic Loli is annoying, loli, and ugly, so no.
Older witch girl is annoying.