Having spent some time on MAL, the community sucks balls and ZoiQ, the creator of that club, is a dick-bag.
It's sad because a year ago MAL had a great community. Intelligent, helpful, decent taste, a place where you could go to discuss anime and other shit. But then you had an influx of newfags in around September and it's gone down hill from there. It doesn't help that most of it's staff are part of the problem. They set horrible examples of how to conduct yourself representing the community. Also, the owner and opperator doesn't give a rats ass about how the community acts on his site. He's happy with only limited moderation to get rid of CP if/when it shows up.
Basically, shit communty, but great for keeping a list.