Eternal Darkness was such a bad game.
Most of the horror elements where so bad it was comical. You had to either laugh or cry.
I played as much as I could before getting to disgusted to continue.
Silent Hill Origins is worth a shot though, if you haven't played it already. The one bad thing, the one terrible thing about the game is that it's based off the storyline for the movie, which was horrible.
Otherwise it's a pretty good Silent Hill game.