We're talking about a show that has a forty something man masturbate to hentai games alongside his daughter. A show that has a twenty something, single virgin teacher who is frustrated with her love life but seeks a steady relationship with a man she can trust. A show that has a semi-smart girl who enjoys some guilty passions, also dreaming of love yet never getting it because of circumstances.
Lucky Star is the highest level of fanservice, a show that offers such concentrated escapism otaku would be willing to more than one DVD.
Beyond this, it's nothing but shit.