Alright, how's this:
Fullmetal Alchemist. I actually like the show, one of my favorite anime. It's still over hyped. In fact, most anime are overhyped because it's the very nature of the subculture to attract fanboys. Now, I don't mean a fan who is a boy, I mean the kind of person who holds X over Y and Z, where Y and Z are everything else. For some reason there can never be people who enjoy X, as well as Y and Z.