Haruhi > Full Metal Panic. Fair enough. Didn't watch Clannad, it seemed like Kanon 2.0 and I wasn't in the mood for a second helping of that but I can see how some people may want more. Lucky Star... just ugh.
Still, can't say I'm surprised. Not like FMP was that good in the first place, first series had a few minor moments where it was ok, then mostly shit. Fumufu I've never watched, it's not my thing but I accept people actually liked that, Second Raid gets a 'better then the first series' award, but still isn't actually that good. OVA was cute, but that's it. It didn't really add anything other then Tessa being moe for a while.
If I had to choose between Haruhi and FMP, I'd go Haruhi every time and I'm not even that much of a fan of it... it's just FMP is mostly disapointing. For all it's hype and popularity, Haruhi isn't a bad series.