The guy on the blog who posted this http://community.livejournal.com/gundam00/152133.html
Mentions how Animedia is a magazine mostly for women YET they have CC, konata and shana there.
Which makes the all idea of "lol yaoi fangirl" bait not true.
The issue is less black and white as you may think.
Also in newtype the have 2 separate lists one for guys and one for the girls.
I can see that they have CC as the number 1 on the list but i dont know the rest.